{short description of image}

Joseph Hogarth

Picture Dealer, Framemaker and Restorer

and

Paxton House, West Drayton


1879

.

Joseph Hogarth

Picture Dealer, Framemaker and Restorer

and

Paxton House, West Drayton


1879

2nd Edition August 2022

kevin.bates.postbox@outlook.com

.

.

 Contents
Documents iii
Preface v
...
1. Joseph Hogarth 1
Will, Codicil and Probate 1
J.M.W. Turner's
'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'
3
2. Paxton House, West Drayton 5
Its Modern Address 5
Modern Map of the area with House Numbers 6
Map Published in 1894 7
Selection of an Area on the 1894 Map for Comparison with the Modern Map 8
Modern Map and 1894 Map Combined 9
1891 Census Records and Comparison with the 1894 Map 10
1894 Map overlaid with 1891 Census list data 11
Deeds of Paxton House 15
3. A Picture Found 16
Finding 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' 16
A Unique Feature 16
4. Building and Planning Activity at 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton 17
Summary of Chapters 1 to 3 17
The origin of 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' 17
Planning Applications at 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton 17
Owner's and Agent's Comments 18
5. Conclusions
'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol' 10
Was 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' removed from Paxton House? 19
...
Index 21
Appendix I
 i

.

.

 Documents and Illustrations
 Joseph Hogarth's Will - Extract 1
Joseph Hogarth's Codicil - Extract 1
Joseph Hogarth's Probate 1
A Page from the 1883 Probate Register 2
Christie's Sale Catalogue 9th July 1864 - Extract, Lots 151 & 152 3
George Redford 'Art Sales' Vol 2, 1888, page 120 4
147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton - Photograph 5
Modern Map of Station Road, West Drayton 6
1894 Map of Station Road, West Drayton 7
1894 Map; Selected Area 8
Modern Map and 1894 Map Combined 9
1894 Map with 1891 Census Information 11
Post Office Directory 1874 - West Drayton (page 863) 12
1891 Census, FreeCen Census List Extracts 13 & 14
Deeds of Paxton House - Records from the National Archives 15
Oil on Canvas; 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' - Photograph 16
J.M.W. Turner, 'Back View of Hotwells House' - Inset 16
Stretcher Detail from 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' 16
Planning Application; 147 Station Road, West Drayton - Extract 17
 iii

.

.

Preface

Joseph Hogarth (1801-1879) was an engraver, publisher, art dealer and picture restorer. He and his business associates are well documented on the internet. In 1854 he published 'Turner and Girtin's Picturesque Views, 60 Years Since' edited by Thomas Miller.

At Christie's sale of 9th July 1864 Joseph Hogarth auctioned two JMW Turner oils and at Christie's sale of 14th March 1866 he auctioned two JMW Turner watercolour-drawings, all four paintings having been formerly in the collections of Rev. Robert Nixon of Foots Cray and, later, his second son Rev. Dr. Francis Russell Nixon, Bishop of Tasmania, who had five JMW Turners in his collection, two oils and three watercolour drawings.

At the 9th July 1864 the two oils were bought in but nonetheless analysis of the sales catalogue shows that one of the pictures, lot 152, was 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'. No further transactions are found for this picture and the inference is that Joseph Hogarth died with it in his possession. The picture could have been abandoned at his business address, 96 Mount Street, Grosvenor Square. However, the business continued after Hogarth's death and if the picture had been at 96 Mount Street then it is likely that there would be some ongoing transactions recorded as indeed there was for the other JMW Turner oil, lot 151, in the sale of 9th July 1864.

Examination of his will and probate suggest a more likely scenario in which he abandoned, or rather 'hid', the picture at his private residence, Paxton House, West Drayton, which he purchased late in 1873. Note that this is not the modern-day Paxton House at Berwick upon Tweed.

Joseph Hogarth's probate shows that he died at Paxton House, West Drayton and the primary purpose of this book is to elucidate its modern address.

Having done so, the following points are considered:

  • That 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol' may have remained hidden there for many years.
  • The timing of its removal.
  • Whether a picture found recently, 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol', was removed from that property.

These points remain unresolved. However, enquiries continue to find the answers.

This second edition includes information, provided by Hillingdon Central services, about house renumbering on Station Road, see Appendix I.

 v

.

.

1. Joseph Hogarth

Will, Codicil and Probate

Joseph Hogarth's probate shows that he died at Paxton House, West Drayton. He died on 9th October 1879 and probate was granted on 12th January 1883. This two year period of administration indicates that his estate was perhaps somewhat complicated.

His will was signed 25th November 1872 whilst he was living at 96, Mount Street.

A codicil to his will was signed on15th August 1874. Whilst Hogarth's address is not written on the codicil it can be seen that his witnesses are from West Drayton. A peculiar phrase in this codicil gives rise to a suspicion that all was not well in Joseph's life. He wrote, "I have the greatest horror of litigation".

Probate was granted on 12th January 1883

 1

.

Joseph Hogarth

Joseph Hogarth appears on a page from the probate register for 1883.

 2

.

Joseph Hogarth

J.M.W Turner's:
'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'

In 1862 Rev. Francis Russell Nixon, Bishop of Tasmania, returned to London from Tasmania bringing with him his art collection which included five works by J.M.W. Turner originally in the possession of his father, Rev. Robert Nixon who had acquired them directly from Turner. There were two oils and three watercolour-drawings which are documented by exhibition catalogues and press reports from Tasmania in 1845 and 1858. Whether directly or indirectly via other dealers, Joseph Hogarth came into possession of at least four of these Turners.

'The two oils were auctioned, being recorded as the property of Hogarth, at a Christies sale commencing on 9th July 1864. Lot 152 was 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol' which Turner had exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1793. In this extract from the sale catalogue the initial 'J' is incorrectly given for Rev. Robert Nixon.



These two lots were unsold. Lot 151 later appeared in the collection of Sir William Richard Drake and was auctioned at his executor's sale. In 1920 it was auctioned in New York in the sale of R. Hall McCormick.

However, 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol' did not emerge again during Joseph Hogarth's lifetime or following his death; this suggests that he may have retained it and, as something which was a valuable possession, deliberately hidden it as part of his attempt to circumnavigate the litigation mentioned in the codicil to his will.

Between 1862 and 1879 there are three addresses associated with Joseph Hogarth; 5 Haymarket, 96 Mount Street and Paxton House, West Drayton. Haymarket and Mount Street were sequential and served as business and residential premises. However, Joseph Hogarth lived in Paxton House, West Drayton from its purchase in 1873 to his death in 1879 whilst the business continued at Mount Street. If he did hide some valuable personal possessions Paxton House would seem to be the most likely hiding place.

 3

.

Joseph Hogarth

George Redford 'Art Sales' Vol 2, 1888, page 120 shows Hogarth as seller.

 4

.

2. Paxton House, West Drayton

Its Modern Address

The location of Joseph Hogarth's Paxton House, West Drayton was found by comparison of: a list of addresses from the 1891 census, an 1894 map and a modern map.

  • 1891 Census records from FreeCen, Middlesex 1891, Uxbridge, Piece No. RG12\1018.
  • 1894 map of Station Road, West Drayton showing individual houses.
  • Modern map of Station Road, West Drayton showing house numbers.

A schedule of documents held by Hillingdon Local Studies, Archives and Museum Services and corresponding entries on the National Archives Discovery website provided sufficient information to place Joseph Hogarth in Paxton House from 31st December 1873 at which time the property was known as 2 Orchard Villas. Hillingdon's Street Naming and Numbering Services confirmed that 2 Orchard Villas is now 149 Station Road.

Additional information from the Post Office Directory of 1874 shows a previous occupant of 2 Orchard Villas, station master Henry Mager, and an Arthur Elve at 1 Orchard Villas.

From these sources a consistent, albeit incomplete, history of this area emerges and is discussed in detail in Appendix I. The present address of Paxton House, originally 2, Orchard Villas, is found to be:

147 & 149 Station Road
West Drayton
Middlesex
UB7 7ND

The oil painting on canvas 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' was sold in Hadleigh, Suffolk on 11th August 2018.

Examination of modern documents show no recent planning or building activity at 149 but does show works carried out on 147 in late 2017 following its sale on 19th July 2017. Correspondence with estate agents and a previous owner of 147 have established that 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' was not recovered from the property prior to that sale. Agents for this purchaser have said by e-mail that, during subsequent renovations, unwanted items cleared from the house were put into a skip for disposal.

The question remains as to whether 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' was removed from 147 (or 149) Station Road, West Drayton during the period 20th July 2017 to 10th August 2018.

 5

...

Paxton House, West Drayton

Modern Map of the Area, with House Numbers

On this map c.2017, 147 Station Road is highlighted in red.

  • The highlighted area accounts for about one third of the site occupied by 147 and 149.
  • Note that directly to the south the next house number ia 153. (Number 151 is set back off the road to the East and is accessable from station Road via a narrow strip of land passing between 149 and 153)
  • Including number 153 there are nine properties set out approximately in a crescent; these are the odd numbers inclusive of 153 to 169. 163 is shown on the map and 171 which follows the nine property sequence is also marked on the map.
  • On the bottom right of the map is a building named as 'Rectory Court'.

 6

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

Map Published in1894

This map shows the same area from an Ordnance Survey map of 1894.

  • At left of centre on this map is a building marked 'School'.
  • On the opposite side of Station Road there is a building spanning two sites delineated by a line drawn from the road approximately halfway across the building and continuing to the eastern boundary of the two sites.
  • To the South of this building there is a narrow strip of land leading to a field behind a row of properties set out in a crescent facing Station Road. (At the North-East corner of the field are a group of buildings which do not appear on the modern map.)
  • On the bottom right of the map is a building marked as 'Vicarage'. It appears in the same area as 'Rectory Court' on the modern map. Rectory Court appears to be a redevelopment of the 1894 Vicarage.
  • Note that between the row of properties set out as a crescent and the Vicarage there are two little buildings set one with its frontage on Station Road and the other behind it.

 7

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

Selection of an Area on the 1894 Map for Comparison with the Modern Map

This map, again of 1894, shows an area highlighted which has been selected as an overlay for the modern map.

  • Note that the selected area includes the School, the Vicarage, part of St. Martin's Church (lower left), the crescent of nine properties to the south of the building opposite the school, and a few buildings to the north - as far as the Six Bells public house.


 8

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

Modern Map and 1894 Map Combined

The highlighted section from page 8 is overlaid onto the modern map:

  • Slight adjustments have been made to achieve the overlay; a little anticlockwise rotation and a minor change to the aspect ratio of the overlay.
  • It can be seen that there is reasonable concordance between the overlay and the modern map for the building opposite the school and the nine properties to the south (although the school is now demolished) .
  • The building opposite the school is 147 and 149 Station Road.
  • The Six Bells (now rebuilt on the same site), the Vicarage (now redeveloped as Rectory Court), and the South-East corner of St. Martin's Church are all aligned within a few metres.

 9

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

1891 Census Records and Comparison with the 1894 Map

As of September 2021 a list of 1891 census records for West Drayton was available on the internet and the section around Station Road was downloaded. (Extracts are reproduced on pages 13 and 14)

That census list shows Paxton House in Station Road, West Drayton.

Properties starting in an area a little to the North and extending to The Vicarage to the South are shown here, the numbers on the left are schedule numbers from the census, not house numbers.

  • 172 Station Road, General Shop
  • 173 Station Road, 1 Hodges Cottages
  • 174 Station Road, 2 Hodges Cottages
  • 175 Station Road, School House
  • 176 Station Road, 1 De Burgh Villas
    please note that in some documents, not included here, this address has been conflated with 'De Burgh Crescent'.
  • 177 Station Road, 2 De Burgh Villas
  • ...... Station Road, 1 Orchard Villas
  • 178 Station Road, 2 Orchard Villas
  • 179 Station Road, Paxton House
  • 180 Station Road, 1 De Burgh Crescent
  • 181 Station Road, 2 De Burgh Crescent
  • ...... Station Road, 3 De Burgh Crescent
  • 182 Station Road, 4 De Burgh Crescent
  • ...... Station Road, 5 De Burgh Crescent
  • 183 Station Road, 6 De Burgh Crescent
  • 184 Station Road, 7 De Burgh Crescent
  • 185 Station Road, 8 De Burgh Crescent
  • ...... Station Road, 9 De Burgh Crescent
  • 186 Station Road, Bagley Lodge
  • 187 Station Road, Ivy Cottage
  • 188 Station Road, The Vicarage

These are compared with the 1894 map on the next page. Properties between The Vicarage and the School are both shown on the map and listed in the census; they show 100% concordance and there can be no doubt that the property known as Paxton House in 1891 was part of the the modern day 147 and 149 Station Road. There have been other sites proposed for Paxton House during the early 20th century. However, Joseph Hogarth died in Paxton House in 1879 so it is the location at that date which is determined and any later revisions, renumbering and so on, are not material in this context but are examined in Appendix I.

 10

.

Paxton House, West Drayton - 1894 Map overlaid with 1891 Census list data

  • Property addresses are coloured as in the preceding list.
  • Note that the census dates from 1891 and the map from 1894. Whilst there are alternatives the timeline is probably as follows:
    • Before 1873 Numbers 1 and 2 Orchard Villas were built; semi-detached villas, schedule numbers 178 & 179. De Burgh Villas, the unoccupied 1 Orchard Villas (shown here) and the nine De Burgh Crescent properties did not exist at this time.
    • Schedule number 178 as 1 Orchard Villas was occupied by Arthur Elve. Schedule number 179 as 2 Orchard Villas was occupied by 32 year old stationmaster, Henry Mager.
    • On 31st December 1873 Joseph Hogarth bought 2, Orchard Villas. (see National Archives Ref: MC6/WD/1)
    • On 7th February 1874 Joseph Hogarth renamed 2, Orchard Villas as Paxton House. (see National Archives Ref: MC6/WD/2 and MC6/WD)
    • Then: The building shown here as 1 Orchard Villas was built and schedule number 178 became 2 Orchard Villas, Mr. & Mrs Elve were still in occupation and Mr Elve died here in 1878.
    • Around this time 1 & 2 De Burgh Villas was built, another semi-detached. Schedule numbers 176 & 177 on this map.
    • In 1879 De Burgh Cresent was built and the leases were assigned on 29th September. [London Metropolitan Archives].
    • In 1879 Joseph Hogarth died on 9th October.
    • In 1883 Probate was granted to Joseph Hogarth's executors. It shows Hogarth's widow, Elizabeth, in occupation of Paxton House.
    • In 1891 Census information shows 1 Orchard Villas unoccupied but shows occupancy at 2, Orchard Villas and Paxton House with Paxton House being next door to 1 De Burgh Crescent. (numbered 180 above, in red)(not to be confused with 1 De Burgh Villas, numbered 176 above, in blue).
    • In 1894 the Ordnance Survey map was published.
11

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

Information for the 1874 issue of the Post Office Directory would likely have been gathered in 1873.

  • In the West Drayton section, col 2, line 19, Henry Mager is recorded as station master. In the alphabetical names section, left column, his address is shown as 2, Orchard Villas.
  • Arthur Elve is shown at 1 Orchard Villas, Joseph Hogarth is shown without an address.
  • In the commercial section (col. 3) Frederick Winship is named as a butcher. In the 1891 census he is shown residing at 1 De Burgh Villas.

 12

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

1891 Census List

The first page, with references.

 13

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

1891 Census List for area around Paxton House

With De Burgh Villas to the north and De Burgh Crescent to the south.

 14

.

Paxton House, West Drayton

Deeds of Paxton House

Records from the National Archives.

Top: This record indicates that Paxton House was previously 2, Orchard Villas; confirmed by the two records below. References to Glenelg and No. 111 Station Road are more likely to be renaming of the property shown as No. 1 Orchard Villas on the census list (see Appendix I). The extract about Mrs Kral's dogs was found in Google Books, 'The pomeranian - A Complete Anthology of the Dog', Vintage Dog Books 2010, ISBN 978-14455-2641-6 in which 'Glenelg' and '111' are in used together. Mr Kral's probate shows that the number, 111 was in use in 1946.
[Another reference, to 121 Station Road, was found in 'A Woman Lived Here' by Alison Vale (2018) ISBN: 978-1-4721-4006-7 Ch 14, '121 Station Road (now razed) ... In the early years of the 1930s, Station Road, West Drayton was ... a pub at number 125, The Six Bells ...', but 125 is the modern number - 121 was probably old numbering (like the Kral's 111). If so, and counting from Glenelg as 111, number 121 would have been 3 De Burgh Crescent which has definitely not been 'razed'.]

Although the compiler of the Hillingdon documents has assumed that Paxton House was renamed Glenelg it is more likely that Glenelg was originally the detached building just to the north. (see Appendix I)

Extract from the probate register for 1946:

KRAL William Casimir Karel otherwise William Casimir Charles
of 111 Station-road West Drayton Middlesex died 4th November
1945 Probate London 12 July to Else Kral widow.
Effects £840 15s 6d.

Left: This record shows Joseph Hogarth's mortgage on 2 Orchard Villas.
Right: Reassignment of the mortgage following the property's change of name to Paxton House.

 15

.

3. A Picture Found

Finding 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol'

On 11th August 2018 a picture was found in Hadleigh Vintage Market (Suffolk). The seller said that it had been recovered together with other items from an attic during a house clearance and sold at a car boot sale.

The picture found in Hadleigh Vintage Market is called 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' named for the location of the scene as determined from two sketches by J.M.W. Turner which are held by Tate Gallery as part of the Turner Bequest.

Turner's depiction of St. Vincent's Rock (an overhanging rock with a smaller dome shaped rock) is seen in his watercolour-drawing on the left, inset, looking towards the riverbank on the Gloucestershire side and on the oil on canvas from the opposite direction, on the right.

A Unique Feature

The picture was found unframed. However, it was partially attached to its stretcher. This stretcher is unique in as much as the joints are of a peculiar design each fitted with a single key which facilitates stretching in both directions.

 16

.

4. Building and Planning Activity at 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton

Summary of Chapters 1 to 3

Chapters 1 to 3 have established a sequence of events in repect of Joseph Hogarth, Paxton House, and J.M.W. Turner's picture 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'.

  • In 1864 Joseph Hogarth was in possession of JMW Turner's picture 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'.
  • Hogarth died at Paxton House, West Drayton in 1879.
  • 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol', last seen in 1864, did not reappear during his lifetime or after his death and may have been hidden in Paxton House.
  • The modern address for Paxton House is 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton.
  • In August 2018 a picture found in Hadleigh, Suffolk which depicts a scene of St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol as J.M.W Turner drew it. This picture was named 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol'

The origin of 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol'

The question now arising is:

  • Was 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' recovered from 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton.

Planning Applications at 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton

'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' was recovered just before August 2018 and sold, first at a car boot sale and then in Hadleigh Vintage Market.

Two planning applications were found. For 149 an application made in 1982 is too old to be of significance. However, an application on 147 was made 25th August 2017 and withdrawn on 9th July 2018. This timing coincides with recovery of the picture, 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol'.

  • Extract from the application of 25th August 2017.
 17

.

Building and Planning Activity at 147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton

Owner's and Agent's Comments

147 Station Road was sold on 19th July 2017 the vendor on this occasion has been contacted and has confirmed that he did not recover the picture.

The planning application above was submitted on 25th August 2017. Agents for this purchaser have said by e-mail that, during subsequent renovations, unwanted items cleared from the house were put into a skip for disposal. There is some mystery surrounding this information as they do not seem to know who, which contractor or house clearance people actually carried out the disposal.

 18

.

5. Conclusions

'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol'

On 20th July 2017 the picture, 'The rising squall, hot wells, from St. Vincent's rock, Bristol' was either still hidden at 147 & 149 Station Road or it was never there. If it was hidden at 147 &149 Station Road it may have been removed and may have been placed in the rubbish skip.

Was 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' removed from Paxton House?

If this picture was removed from Paxton House, (147 & 149 Station Road, West Drayton) the former home of Joseph Hogarth, the relevant dates are:

  • Removed from the property after 20th July 2017.
  • Sold at a car boot sale before 10th August 2018.
  • Then sold in Hadleigh Vintage Market on 11th August 2018.

Enquiries - to trace the two traders involved and to find out whether 'Squall at St. Vincent's Rock, Bristol' was removed from 147 Station Road and subsequently sold at a car boot sale - are ongoing as at June 2022.

 19

.

.

Index

Administration, Period Of; 1
Census; 10, 11, 13, 14
Christie's Sale, 3
Codicil; 1
De Burgh Villas; 5, 11
De Burgh Crescent; 11
Deeds of Paxton House; 15
Drake, Sir William Richard; 3
Haymarket; 3
Hidden (assets); 3, 19
Litigation, Horror Of; 1
McCormick, R. Hall; 3
Mount Street; 3
National Archives; 15
Nixon, Francis Russell, Bishop of Tasmania; 3
Orchard Villas; 5, 11, 12
Overlay, Map; 9
Paxton House; 1, 5, 15, 19
Planning; 17
Post Office Directory; 12
Probate; 1, 2
Redford, George, Art Sales; 4
Renumbering of Houses, Relevance of; 10
Royal Academy, 3
St. Vincent's Rock; 5, 15, 16
School; 8
Six Bells; 8
Station Road; 5-11, 17
Stretcher, Unique Feature; 16
Tasmania, Bishop Of; 3
Turner, J.M.W. 'The Rising Squall; 3, 10
West Drayton; 1
Will; 1
 21

.

Appendix I

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

I

This exercise was undertaken to identify the location of Paxton House in 1879, the year in which Joseph Hogarth died.

The main evidential features are:

  • In the street naming and numbering records of Hillingdon Council 'Paxton House' is not recorded. In these records the semi detached property now known as 147 and 149 Station Road was originally known as 1 & 2 Orchard Villas. We have no way of knowing which side of the semi-detached building was number 1 and which was number 2. Conventionally, when viewed from the street, number 1 would be on the left hand side and that is the convention used in this exercise.
  • It is clear from the records described here as 'Deeds of Paxton House', recorded in the National Archives, that Joseph Hogarth bought 2 Orchard Villas on 31st December 1873. It is also reasonably clear that this was the property that he (unofficially) renamed 'Paxton House'

Prima facie then, 'Paxton House' was the building now known as 149 Station Road. However, there is uncertainty as to the internal arrangements; as mentioned above there is uncertainty as to which side was number 2, roof spaces were often cojoined (The picture, 'Squall at St Vincent's Rock, Bristol', and other valuables were said to have been removed from an attic during house clearance) and boundaries changed.

Further uncertainty was introduced by the compiler of the National Archives Records who recorded that Paxton House was formerly known as '2 Orchard Villas, subsequently 'Glenelg', now 111 Station Road'. This cannot be correct; Hillingdon's street numbering records show that the original 2 Orchard Villas (Joseph Hogarth's 'Paxton House') became No.115 in a renumbering that took place in 1931. There is documentary evidence that 'Glenelg' was 111 Station Road in or around 1936 and therefore 'Paxton House' and 'Glenelg' were different buildings.

 i

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

I

The properties involved in this appraisal are clustered around the present 147 & 149 Station Road which is now a semi-detached house, 147 being an HMO and 149 being divided internally into four privately owned appartments. Original buildings to the north, Glenelg and 1 & 2 De Burgh Villas, have been destroyed. To the south however, nine addresses formerly known as 1 to 9 De Burgh Crescent still stand essentially as they were in the late nineteenth century. There is considerable confusion in certain narratives between 1 & 2 De Burgh Villas and 1 to 9 De Burgh Crescent. The difference (and thus the precise location of De Burgh Crescent) is best illustrated as a map:

 ii

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Overview of Documents

I

It has not been possible to look at every original document. However, lists of archives are found to be sufficiently detailed to derive information required for this exercise and these lists are illustrated along with other documents to assist future researchers. It should be mentioned that there was some evidence that suggested previous research into this matter had been carried out; for example the will of Joseph Hogarth had been previously requested.

Some documents refer to specific points in time, others are more general and cover a number of years. Generally, the illustrations cover relevant parts of documents. This information is presented here as a year by year summary and discussion of evidence extracted followed by illustrations of the documents themselves. Private e-mails are not illustrated. E-mails from companies and public institutions are selectively reproduced.

Some documents have already been illustrated in the text; these are indicated in italics, with a few exceptions they are not duplicated in this appendix.

List of documents examined for the summary and illustrations:

  • Directories
    • Post Office Directory 1855, pages 563 & 564
    • Post Office Directory 1874, page 863 (see text: page 12)
    • Kelly's Directory 1894, pages 342 & 343
    • Kelly's Directory 1899, pages 374 & 375
    • Kelly's Directory 1914, pages 463 & 464
    • Middlesex Pub Directory
  • Public Archives
    • Census List of 1891, 7 pages
    • Deeds of Paxton House - Documents held at Hillingdon and listed by National Archives, 3 pages (see also: text page 15)
    • National Archives, Home Office Documents, 1 page
    • De Burgh Documents List from London Metropolitan Archives, 7 pages
    • Commonwealth War Graves Commission
  • Wills, Codicils and Probates
    • Joseph Hogarth's Codicil of 1874 (see text: page 1)
    • Probate of Joseph Hogarth (see text: page 1)
    • Probate of Arthur Charles Elve 1878
    • Probate of William Kral
  • Books and E-mails
    • Mrs. E. Kral's Pomeranians
    • Hillingdon Street Naming and Numbering (e-mail)
  • Maps
    • 1864 Ordnance Survey Map
    • 1873 Postulated, reconstruction based on the documents
    • 1877 Postulated, reconstruction based on the documents
    • 1894 Ordnance Survey Composite with 1891 Census Data
    • 1935 Ordnance Survey Map (see: text page 6)
 iii

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

Information in italics is derived; not directly in the document.

1855

Post Office 1855

  • Frederick Winship (sen.) is shown as butcher but no address given (It cannot be 1 De Burgh Villas because this property does not exist on the 1864 map)
  • James Stacey, brickmaker, is shown, no address.
  • School is shown as 'small National school for girls'
  • George Classon is listed but no address (later also listed 1874, later found at 'Swains')
  • Timothy Painter - no address (in 1874 Mrs Painter is shown so Timothy has died, FreeBMD & Probate 28th Jan 1874 age 71, will ordered to get address)
  • Drayton House - Edward Henry Rickards

1864

Ordnance Survey Map of 1864

  • Drayton House - is shown
  • Swains - is shown
  • 1, 2 & 3 Elmtree Cottages - Nos. 1 and 2 only are shown; No.1 was probably the blacksmith.
  • Rooks Farm Buildings - are shown
  • 1 & 2 Purton Villas are absent, not yet built
  • Warwick and York Villas are absent, not yet built
  • Two small cottages and the large house, later schedules 159 to 162, are shown
  • The Six Bells Public House - Two buildings are shown on the site
    (on the 1891 census these are Eight Bells, scedule 163, to the north and Six Bells, schedule 164, to the south.)
    (the outbuildings to the south of the Six Bells are clearly absent from this map)
  • The Villas opposite the Six Bells site are shown, later schedules 165 and 166
  • Venetia Cottage - is shown
  • Laurel Cottage - is shown
  • The small cottage - is shown; but not on its own site, it is on the same site as Laurel Cottage
  • The cottage and general shop - is shown, this was later schedule 172 on the 1891 census
  • Hodges Cottages - (later, schedules 173 & 174) are shown
  • School - shown as 'National School for Boys and Girls'
  • All the buildings from De Burgh Villas to De Burgh Crescent are absent, not yet built.
  • Bagley Lodge, Ivy Cottage and the Vicarage are shown

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1873

  • 1 Orchard Villas - From the Deeds of Paxton House it is clear that 2 Orchard Villas existed at this time so it is safe to assume the existence of 1 Orchard Villas
  • 2 Orchard Villas - Joseph Hogarth bought it at the end of the year and Henry Mager is shown here in Post Office directory 1874 so it is safe to assume the existence of 2 Orchard Villas in 1873

1874

Deeds Of Paxton House 1874

  • 2 Orchard Villas - Joseph Hogarth 31/12/1873 MC6/WD/1
  • Paxton House (previously 2 Orchard Villas) - Joseph Hogarth 7/2/1874 MC6/WD/2

Post Office 1874

  • Frederick Winship is shown as butcher but no address
  • Joseph Hogarth is shown but no address
  • Charles Thatcher is on 'The Green' and Misses Thatcher are present with no address. Thatcher brothers are listed in the commercial section.
  • John Sands Reed is shown but no address (later 2 De Burgh Crescent which was not built at this time)
  • George Classon is listed no address (previously appeared in 1855)
  • Drayton House -Edward Henry Rickards (Drayton House originally known as the Burroughs, see Whitley 1923)
  • Warwick Villa - semi detached with York Villa
  • York Villa - George Bolton (later schedule 158 on 1891 census)
  • Six Bells - William Baker
  • 1 Orchard Villas - Arthur Elve coal merchant (who died June 1878 age 46 at 2 Orchard Villas probably renumbered)
  • 2 Orchard Villas - Henry Mager, station master (who by 1881 census was in Cookham, Berkshire)

Joseph Hogarth's Codicil 1874

  • Thatcher, initial probably S but could be F or J is shown in West Drayton but no address - this was 15th August '74 (The transcript is all written by the same person and the initial J is found on 'J Hogarth' just above and 'January' just below - they are different but share pen direction. However, just above the codicil there is 'Signed' and 'Street' with almost identical 'S' to the Thatcher initial.)
  • E. Lowe is shown in West Drayton but no address - this was 15th August '74

Middlesex Pub Dirtectory 1874

  • Six Bells - William Baker is shown as the innkeeper.

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1877

  • At this time there is still no sign of 1 & 2 De Burgh Villas and it is clear that De Burgh Crescent has not yet been built.
  • 1 Orchard Villas, New Building ? - If a new house was built just to the north of the original 1&2 Orchard Villas around this time the two buildings, new and the semi-detached existing house, may have been respectively, 1 Orchard Villas (detached), 2 Orchard Villas (north semi) and Paxton House (south semi)
  • 2 Orchard Villas (previously known as 1 Orchard Villas) - Elve was in occupation
  • Paxton House (previously 2 Orchard Villas) - Hogarth in occupation

1878

Probate of Arthur Charles Elve 1878

  • 2 Orchard Villas, (previously 1 Orchard Villas ?) Arthur Charles Elve (died here), widow, Elizabeth remained
    Elve died in June 1878 and the house had been renumbered at this time. Construction of the new house must have been completed for the renumbering to have taken place so it has been shown as under construction in 1877 although it could have been earlier.
    There are other possibilities. The basic evidential material shows that, in 1874, Arthur Charles Elve lived at 1 Orchard Villas and that 2 Orchard Villas had been renamed 'Paxton House'. Above it has been assumed that a new building took the address '1 Orchard Villas' and that the original 1 Orchard Villas was renamed '2 Orchard Villas'. None of this renaming appears to have been official; Hillingdon Street Naming and Numbering services have recorded just 1 and 2 Orchard Villas renamed as 113 and 115 Station Road in 1931 then 147 and 149 in 1963. Apart from Elve's probate there is no evidence of new building until its tentative entry in the 1891 census (as 1 Orchard Villas) and then as 'Glenelg' in 1894. So it is possible that the new building, Glenelg, was not built until 1893/94. How then can the 1878 Elve probate evidence and the 1891 census schedules (showing both 1 and 2 Orchard Villas and Paxton House) be reconciled. The answer lies in the plan of 1 and 2 Orchard Villas. From the 1894 map the building appears to be double bay fronted with porches on each side. On the modern photograph; however,
     ...
    the potential for dividing the building into three addresses is clear. Perhaps this was the layout in the early years; around 1877 to 1892. So the 1891 census information may simply be a result of this (unofficial) division of the property into three instead of two.

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1879

Deeds Of Paxton House 1879

  • 2 Orchard Villas - Note of 7th May 1879 re mortgage from J P Poncione, MC6/WD/3 (silent as to mortgagor [and mortgagee])

Probate of Joseph Hogarth

  • Paxton House - Joseph Hogarth died here, widow Elizabeth remained until at least 12th January 1883 when her address was shown on the probate.

De Burgh Documents List

  • 1 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0298 (filed as 1880)
  • 2 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0298 (filed as 1880)
  • 3 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0298 (filed as 1880)
  • 4 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0298 (filed as 1880)
  • 5 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0306,0307(filed as 1880)
  • 6 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0306,0307(filed as 1880)
  • 7 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0310-0312+0313+0331(filed as 1881)
  • 8 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0310-0312+0313+0331(filed as 1881)
  • 9 De Burgh Crescent - Lease granted 99 years from29th September 1879 - ACC/1386/0310-0312+0313+0331(filed as 1881)

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1883

Probate of Joseph Hogarth

  • Paxton House - Probate was granted on 12th January. His widow Elizabeth was an executor and her address was shown as Paxton House.

1888

Deeds Of Paxton House 1888

  • Paxton House - J Hogarth & Sons, mortgage to City Bank MC6/WD/4 10th August 1888

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1891

On the census list there is an empty house named 1 Orchard Villas (followed by 2 Orchard Villas then Paxton House). Paxton House was originally 2 Orchard Villas, what is now 2 Orchard Villas was previously 1 Orchard Villas. The empty house called 1 Orchard Villas here appears to be Glenelg.
On the census list is the first sighting of 1 & 2 De Burgh Villas. They are both occupied.

Deeds Of Paxton House 1891

  • Paxton House - J Hogarth & Sons in bankruptcy; City Bank repossession and sale to Thomas Pocock (the mortgage remains with City Bank) MC6/WD/5,MC6/WD/6 & MC6/WD/7. At the same time:
    • 2 Orchard Villas is occupied by Hillyer et al - 2 Orchard Villas and Paxton House are clearly different properties.
    • Paxton House is occupied by William C. Thompson et al - these may have been Hogarth & Co. tenants

Census List of 1891

  • Drayton House - William Stacey (age 50) and his family
  • Swains - George Classon aged 85, wife Mary 64 and daughter Mary R, 28
  • 1 De Burgh Villas - Frederick Winship (age 40) and his family
  • 2 De Burgh Villas - James G. Moon, electrical engineer, and his family, neice (Hayden) & servant (Wignell)
  • 1 Orchard Villas - No schedule is associated with this address (this house was later known as 'Glenelg')
  • 2 Orchard Villas - Joseph Hillyer & family, tenants: 2 Nichols & Holt, servant: George
  • Paxton House - William C. Thompson & family, servants: Watts & Kite
  • 1 De Burgh Crescent - Cecil Powell & family
  • 2 De Burgh Crescent - John S. Reed & family
  • 3 De Burgh Crescent - (wrongly printed as '5') no scedule
  • 4 De Burgh Crescent - Robert A Strickland & family, Wigg, servants: Benton & Gunton (poss. should both be the same?)
  • 5 De Burgh Crescent - no schedule
  • 6 De Burgh Crescent - Harriett Domoney & Rose, Maria Lake, lodger: Julia F. Richards
  • 7 De Burgh Crescent - schedule 184 assigned but no occupants recorded
  • 8 De Burgh Crescent - John W. Hardy & family, Mead, Romanis & Grove
  • 9 De Burgh Crescent - no schedule

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1892

Deeds Of Paxton House 1892

  • Paxton House - Frank Thatcher takes a lease from Thomas Pocock MC6/WD/8 9th January
  • Paxton House - Sold by City Bank to William Stacy MC6/WD/9 on 20th May 1892; (Frank Thatcher still in occupation is now William Stacy's tenant) MC6/10 to 16 all appear to relate to this sale which completed before 8th July.

1894

Kelly's 1894

Frederick Winship (age 43) is shown as dairyman but no address (4 years previously he was at 1 De Burgh Villas)

  • Drayton House - William Stacey
  • Swains - George Classon
  • 2 De Burgh Villas - Henry C. Law
  • Glenelg - Frank Thatcher
  • Elmside, De Burgh Crescent - Albert Atkinson
  • 2 De Burgh Crescent - John Sands Reed
  • 3 De Burgh Crescent - Henry B. Knight
  • 4 De Burgh Crescent - Robert Alexander Strickland
  • 8 De Burgh Crescent - Mrs. Esther Hardy
  • 9 De Burgh Crescent - John Henry Grove

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1899

Kelly's 1899

  • Frederick Winship (age 48) is shown as butcher & dairyman but no address (8 years previously he was at 1 De Burgh Villas)
  • Frank Thatcher is shown in 'Oakleigh' and as consulting brewer
  • Drayton House - William Stacey
  • Swains - Miss Classon (George may have died)
  • Elmside, De Burgh Crescent - Albert Atkinson
  • 2 De Burgh Crescent - John Sands Reed
  • 3 De Burgh Crescent - Commander Francis William Cobb RN
  • 4 De Burgh Crescent - Robert Alexander Strickland
  • 6 De Burgh Crescent - Frank Potter
  • 7 De Burgh Crescent - Mrs. Esther Hardy
  • 8 De Burgh Crescent - Arthur Belch
  • 9 De Burgh Crescent - John Henry Grove

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1914

Kelly's 1914

  • Frederick Winship (age 63) is shown as butcher but no address (23 years previously he was at 1 De Burgh Villas)
  • Frank Potter is shown in 'Elruge'
  • Drayton House - William S. Stacy (age 73)
  • Swains - Miss Classon
  • Glenelg - William Ray (Mrs. Ray is in 'Eastdean')
  • 1 Orchard Villas - William Henry Lea, collector of taxes
  • Elmside, (De Burgh Crescent, see Kelly's 1899) Lady Bruce
  • 2 De Burgh Crescent - John Sands Reed
  • 4 De Burgh Crescent - Ferdinand von Madaler
  • 3 De Burgh Crescent - no entry for this address
  • 5 De Burgh Crescent - Thomas Alfred Dynes
  • 6 De Burgh Crescent - Mrs. Wallace Price
  • 7 De Burgh Crescent - George Arthur Strickland
  • 8 De Burgh Crescent - Jesse Ballard
  • 9 De Burgh Crescent - William Robert Pottell

1915

National Archives, Home Office, Naturalisation Certificate: Kral

  • William Casimir Karel Kral is shown in West Drayton but no address. (He later shows up in 'Gleneng') HO 334/76/311 & HO 144/1333/256423

West Drayton by John Davies (e-mail 2, not illustrated)

  • 'Mr. Kral originally lived in Furzeham Road and subsequently moved to a large house opposite the library'. [from 'West Drayton Historian - No. 96 (September 1990)]] (The library must have been the modern building; on the 1935 map this site was still shown as a school and the outline of the school building was the same as that on the 1894 map and quite different from the modern library (see: text page 6) - Kral was in Glenelg by 1919)

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1916

Commonwealth War Graves Commission

  • 1 Orchard Villas - William Henry Lea and wife Annie, son Wilfed Vernon Lea (deceased)

1919

Deeds of Paxton House

  • Glenelg - William Kral, purchase of Glenelg (from William Stacy), mortgagee William Stacy; MC6/WD/17, 18 & 19. Kral moved here from Furzeham Road.

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House

Year by Year Summary of Documents

I

1923

Whitley, West Drayton

  • Drayton house demolished 1923 (originally known as the Burroughs)

1931

Hillingdon Street Naming and Numbering - e-mail

  • 1 De Burgh Villas became 109 Station Road
  • 2 De Burgh Villas became 109 Station Road
  • Glenelg became 111 Station Road
  • 1 Orchard Villas (as recorded on their registers) became 113 Station Road
  • 2 Orchard Villas (as recorded on their registers) became 115 Station Road
  • 1 De Burgh Crescent became 117 (because there is no mention of Paxton House)

1936

Mrs. E Kral's Pomeranians

  • 111 Station Road - Mrs Kral's business shown at 'Glenelg', 111 Station Road. This extract about Mrs Kral's dogs was found in Google Books, 'The pomeranian - A Complete Anthology of the Dog', Vintage Dog Books 2010, ISBN 978-14455-2641-6 in which 'Glenelg' and '111' are in used together. (the date is approximate and picked up from the context of the text)

1945

William Kral Probate

  • 111 Station Road - William Kral (deceased) and wife Else Kral

1963

Hillingdon Street Naming and Numbering - e-mail

  • 113 Station Road (previously 1 Orchard Villas) became 147 Station Road
  • 115 Station Road (previously 2 Orchard Villas) became 149 Station Road

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

{short description of image}

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Directories

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - 1891 Census Schedules

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - Deeds of Paxton House

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - Deeds of Paxton House

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - Deeds of Paxton House

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - National Archives, Home Office Documents

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - De Burgh Documents List

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Public Archives - Commonwealth War Graves Commission

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Wills, Codicils and Probates - Elve at 2 Orchard Villas

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Wills, Codicils and Probates - Kral at 111 Station Road

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Books and E-Mails

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Books and E-Mails

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Maps

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Maps

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Maps

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - Maps

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - X

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - X

I

.

Finding the Location Of Paxton House
Documents - X

I

.